guide

Two charts of the same index can measure different returns

Check dividend treatment before comparing an index chart with investment performance.

By MyForexWorld Editorial Team ·

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Read the return type

S&P distinguishes price return from total return that incorporates reinvested income. Matching index names alone is insufficient. Record the exact series identifier and return type before using two charts to judge relative performance.

Use a one-period illustration

In a fictional one-period example, a holding starts at 100, ends at 102 and pays 3 in cash. Price change is 2%; price plus that cash is 5% of the starting value before costs and taxes. This simplified arithmetic is not a full multi-period index methodology or a claim about an actual fund.

Make comparisons reproducible

Align dates, currency and return conventions, including any net-versus-gross designation. Keep the published series source. Do not present an index’s theoretical reinvestment as evidence of a reader’s actual cash receipts. A personal result also needs transaction timing and applicable costs. If the chart supplier does not identify its series, label the comparison incomplete rather than selecting the more flattering curve.

Keep a chart comparison card

For each line, save the provider, series name, return type, currency, start and end dates. Add whether values were rebased for display. Rebased lines can make relative growth easier to see, but the chosen starting point still matters. Do not describe the plotted level as money a reader could withdraw. The card should let another person reproduce the same comparison without guessing which similarly named index series was selected.

Keep a chart comparison card
CheckWhy
Return typeDividend treatment
CurrencySame measurement unit
DatesSame comparison interval

Article sources

  1. Methodology Matters ↗ S&P Dow Jones Indices