guide

Tracking difference and tracking error answer different questions

Distinguish the return gap from variation in that gap when comparing a fund with a benchmark.

By MyForexWorld Editorial Team ·

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Two questions

MSCI describes tracking error as dispersion of excess returns relative to a benchmark. That is different from simply subtracting the benchmark return from a fund return over a chosen period. One asks how variable the deviations were; the other describes a return gap.

Use a deliberately small example

Imagine two fictional sequences of periodic gaps: A has minus 1, minus 1, minus 1 percentage points; B has minus 3, plus 1, minus 1. Both average minus 1, but B varies more. This is not an annualised tracking-error calculation or a compounded fund return; it isolates why an average cannot describe dispersion.

Match the measurement settings

Before comparing published figures, record benchmark version, currency, period, observation frequency and annualisation convention. Keep gross and net return series distinct. If definitions differ, do not rank the figures as equivalent. A low tracking error also does not imply a positive return: following a falling benchmark closely can still produce a loss.

Do not mix a gap with a standard deviation

A factsheet may report one return gap for a long period and another statistic based on repeated shorter observations. Copy both definitions before comparing them. You cannot reconstruct dispersion from a single start-to-finish return. Nor should the simple average in our classroom example be relabelled a compounded result. Keep calculations at their stated level and ask for the underlying frequency if a published tracking-error figure cannot be interpreted.

Do not mix a gap with a standard deviation
MeasureQuestion
Return gapHow far apart over the period?
DispersionHow variable were deviations?
SettingsAre figures comparable?

Article sources

  1. MSCI IndexMetrics ↗ MSCI